40 Comments
User's avatar
William L Miller's avatar

The 2022 election in Brazil rejected oligarchs and a criminal eventually convicted in 2025 and the election in 2026 had a similar result in 2026 rejecting oligarchs again and the son of the convicted criminal. But Trump was elected in America in 2024 as a disgusting convicted criminal felon who is constantly lying, incited insurrection on January 6, 2021 and should be in jail. Trump was elected and supported by conservative billionaire Republicans to immediately install a lawless fascist autocracy in 2025 as planned in Project 2025. And Republicans in Congress have supported Trump and his billionaire oligarch oil buddies with tax cuts, low wages, cuts to healthcare and food (SNAP …) and with wars and tariffs causing the destruction of affordability and ICE raids with murders of innocent American citizens. Republicans have attacked democracy, healthcare and science for decades since the 1970s and Trump with RFKJr confirmed by Republicans is just a continuation of the attack. But Trump and everything he does is still supported by 50 million conservative Republican voters who are largely white male supremacists who hate women, democracy, immigrants, intelligence, truth and the rule of law. Vote out all Republicans and vote in progressive Democrats.

Pamela A. Miller's avatar

And don't forget the decimation of public education over the past 40+ years. Nothing kills a progressive democracy like lack of education.

imhumanru's avatar

And now AI is dumbing down youth even more. The US is heading toward a country that will be very much like portrayed in the comedy "Idiocracy". Except it isn't funny when it is becoming real.

Barbara's avatar

Totally agree with your comments but please...use some punctuation.

William L Miller's avatar

Edited my comment now with punctuation as you suggested

Jeffrey Hobbs's avatar

Where power, and the ones who hold it, is not checked, fascism and militarism will take over. Unfortunately, authoritarianism is humanity's default setting, based as it is in emotions of fear, hate, and greed. It takes work and effort to maintain a democracy, especially a social democracy, which is based on knowledge, truth, trust, and maturity.

Luther Johnson's avatar

A 'conservative' is someone who has already got his, and now doesn't want anything to change.

Barbara's avatar

Perfect succinct description.

Tomonthebeach's avatar

Reaganism, as Reagan described it, is what fascist MAGAism is today. It brings to mind pet dogs in the dining room eagerly sitting with their tongues hanging out, hoping for table scraps to trickle down to the floor so they can share in the feast. Sadly, that metaphor still aptly describes our capitalist democracy, where we have the illusion of prosperity rather than the real deal.

As Thom notes, Trump's view of the economy is very positive. Billionaires do not buy groceries or fuel for their limos. They have people for that. The only economic indicators they experience are reflected in the stock market and their personal holdings. Corrupt Trump has more than doubled his wealth since taking office. My ETFs are all in the red since last May. I do not expect Santa Claus to turn them green for Christmas. Every economist I know - Nobelist Paul Krugman especially - is predicting a recession in 2027, maybe sooner if Trump screws up Iran much more.

Tom Halstead's avatar

An underlying question: Why is Democratic leadership seemingly satisfied with fascism lite, reliably working to undermine the efforts of anyone who personifies the resistance, even to the extent of parroting fascist lies and misrepresentations about their qualifications and intentions? Try getting a straight answer from Schumer, Gillibrand, Jeffries, Carville, Tanden, etc., about Bernie, AOC, Mamdani, El-Sayed, Angie Nixon, etc. One obvious answer: They fear upsetting their cash cows, especially those that support their own corruption (see: AIPAC). Defeating fascism will be pointless if we fail to clean up our own house. Bernie says there shouldn’t be any billionaires; that’d be a good place to start.

Frank's avatar

Apparently there is nobody willing to challenge Schumer for Democratic leadership in the Senate. Pretty damn sad state of affairs.

Tom Halstead's avatar

My hope is that likely challengers are keeping their powder dry ‘til after the election.

Judy W.'s avatar

Leadership of the Senate rightfully should go to the one who has earned it - Sen. Bernie Sanders.

Frank's avatar

You do realize that Bernie is a party of one in the Senate. He isn’t a member of the Democratic Party by his own choosing.

Judy W.'s avatar

Frank, you must know that either Sanders or Angus King of Maine, the 2 Independents, could become the Senate Majority Leader if elected.

Protect the Vote's avatar

Absolutely! It's because the Democratic establishment is a form of MAGA just in sheep's clothing. Through Indivisible that will be changing...Schumer Jeffries have got to go.

Tom Halstead's avatar

Funny you mentioned that. Watching Rachel one evening I learned that Hakeem was unhappy with Indivisible. I immediately paused the show, dashed to my iPad, signed into ActBlue, and became a monthly supporter. With an endorsement like that, how could I resist!?!

Sir Okie Doke's avatar

I watched the CLOSETocracy documentary last night. In it, one of the men interviewed, Cory Burns, alleges that the client he later identified as US Senator Lindsey Graham said something to the effect of:

"I really like to be degraded. The more degrading, the better."

I say that the above applies to Any "American" who votes for "Any" GOP candidate, Anywhere.

#VOTE BLUE

#MUSK and the GOP are BUGs, NOT Features of the US Gov't

#NO VOTES for the Kiddie Rapist's Minions

Leigh Horne's avatar

You wrote: "The reality is they’re not “conserving” anything. They’re instead echoing the thousands of years of modern history of kings and kingdoms where the ruler had absolute, life-or-death power over a nation’s subjects, and citizenship and freedom were both dependent on his whim."

And in contrast you briefly described the general structure of our Native American, so-called tribal societies, which for the most part were horizontally organized and recognized that being a 'chief' was just a job with the aim of bettering society as a whole. You mention that our founders drew upon this view and some of the forms of at least one of those groups, The Illinois Confederacy, which lasted for more than 600 years before the combination of European 'guns and germs' resulted in their failures. How sad some of those founders must be that their aspirations have been and continue to be ground into the mud o historic greed and privilege.

But those roots live on in us. Only time will tell if we can again grow a society worth the name on our shores.

PS I read somewhere recently that 'conservatism is a personality disorder.' Wish I could remember where.

Protect the Vote's avatar

Demand Full Accountability: Response To The Tired GOP Messaging

As Indivisible has said aloud, WE the People are watching what you do with the power the people have vested in the representatives WE send to Washington. WE expect accountability. If you don't, you'll be a one time representative. That's why the fascists in charge right now are lawyering up and Cheeto is talking about blanket pardons for the staff.

Long term this fascist Heritage Foundation/Project 2025 Republican party regardless of what they say should not be elected dogcatcher for the next 12y. "We were just kidding" "they made us do it" "we're changing our ways" are big smoke screens. These bastards are beholden to the billionaire/technocrat class and have shown clearly that they will never be supporting the decimated working class in the country. Fuck them!! WE the People have seen enough of this Reagan crowd with their bullshit trickle down economics. What a bunch of crap that was.

In the end the "conservative" group of billionaires hide behind the facade of "fiscal responsibility" only to be responsible to much of the $40T debt that will bankrupt the country. This immoral group is fueled by personal and corporate greed and have hoodwinked a large part of the electorate to believe they really care about the people they represent. It's preposterous and yet people believe their crap. Don't believe what they say, watch what they do.

Barry's avatar

On a slightly different theme, I have been watching videos of Sheldon Whitehouse & Jamie Raskin. They seem to be ethical, smart & knowledgeable. I don't know if they are charismatic enough to be President. That doesn't matter to me, but it does attract people. Gavin Newsom has charisma, but I question his commitment to the average person. To repair Trump's financial & reputational damage will take skill & determination. Hopefully the Democratic party can assemble a team to quickly start the process of healing.

Protect the Vote's avatar

Sheldon for POTUS Gavin is Democratic establishment

William Whitman's avatar

Now I really won't sleep tonight. I knew all that, but when you string it all together like that, it is truly terrifying. I hope Trump has done enough damage to make this a real inflection point so we can close the door on this fascist bullshit for a generation.

Judith Green's avatar

An incisive summary! Thanks.

Donald Laghezza's avatar

With his current essay, Thom has opened the door to an underlying issue that both explains and transcends the current imminent danger we are in. And, it is perhaps the first time I disagree with Thom’s core message.

If I read his position correctly, he tells us that conservatism “thrives on fear and resentment while it embraces violence, authoritarianism, and great wealth…” To my mind, and in my experience, this is wrong. If we replace the term “wealth” with “power”, Thom will have also given us a perfect definition of Soviet style communism.

No, we have to look deeper into this because it is exactly this misrepresentation and purposeful abuse of meaning that is super-charging the descent into mindless choices that has allowed millions of people to surrender any form of critical thinking when it comes to making socio-political choices.

My background began with twelve years of Catholic education back when kids in this country – whether in public or private school – really got an education. Roughly during the ‘50s and ‘60s. Until university I was what I believed was “conservative”.

If someone had asked me what I meant by conservative, I would have said it means I do not agree with the state owning everything. Clearly, I was affected by the Soviet boogeyman image. Now, I understand that fear of state ownership of everything was used by those who wanted to reduce to zero community control of all forms of wealth.

Events, and my ability to understand them, changed my position. Among them were JFK’s killing, Civil Rights action, and the war in Vietnam.

More importantly, I received a deep education in history. Two things I remember clearly. One was a high school teacher telling us that America is a constant struggle for balance between Liberty and Equality.

And, two, in college, a professor of American History – my undergrad major -- impressing upon us that when the founders spoke of Liberty, they meant the RIGHT TO OWN PROPERTY: A right denied them, and their immigrating forefathers, by power in Europe.

So, if we can agree that in order to define Conservative, we should know what is balanced against it, I would say it the definition must be a person’s placing an emphasis upon Liberty… to own some part of the commonwealth, as opposed to Equality… the right for all to share freely in the common wealth.

If I am asked to consider the bastardized form of Conservative that Thom describes, then, yes, it is an infection. I might add just as much as is Bolshevism an infection on Equality.

Is it of value to take the time and make the effort to take these false constructs out of the hands of FOX, or the PRC’s messaging machine? I cannot speak for China, but I think there is real and lasting value in framing basic understanding of why MAGA is not true American Conservatism. And then to take out of the Alt-Right’s echo chamber’s hands the ability to use this false construct.

Instead of damning Conservatism and Conservatives, why not damn the liars and expose their fouling legitimate positions on liberty and explain how, as a nation, we must open a deep, constant, and forward-looking discussion, as a people, on where we all think the balance between Liberty and Equality lies.

DL

William L Miller's avatar

Donald

Conservative politics and economics can be traced to FDR’s recovery using strong progressive federal regulations to recover from the Republican caused Great Depression in the 1930s, FDR’s WW2 win to stop fascist Germany and LBJ civil & voting rights enacted with new laws in the 1960s that ended Jim Crow. All those progressive actions by a strong federal government led to the 1971 Powell Memo that launched the attack on democracy that led to Trump’s lawless fascist autocracy. The attack came from anti-New Deal conservatives and business groups (such as the American Liberty League) organized to resist President Franklin D. Roosevelt's sweeping federal regulations and welfare programs during the Great Depression. Conservatives recognized that FDR had successfully justified his progressive policies as social support of the Christian principles of caring for the sick hungry and poor. So conservatives created a counter argument by lying that government imposed support such as Social Security denied the LIBERTY that Jesus believed was essential to a faithful good life. Conservatives used that argument to justify opposition of regulation by government for civil rights and taxing wealth people. The argument got Reagan elected to implement tax cuts for the wealthy and corporations and implement opposition to regulations on corporations that protect labor rights such as fair wages and implement trickle down economics which destroyed affordability but enabled Republicans to gain control of SCOTUS implement Citizens United, gain power and eventually implement a lawless fascist autocracy under Trump as leader of the Republican Party. The autocracy was the intended result of the attack on democracy that began with the 1971 Powell Memo.

Donald Laghezza's avatar

William,

thank you for your comment. However, you are doing exactly what I suggested we avoid... Arguing with the 5,000 foot level "conservative" poseurs on every tactical move they make using their faux conservative tag to obscure their ulterior motives.

If we are to surround the opposition and disarm them, we must first remove the cloak of reasonable discourse.

The men... and it is always men... whom you name are simply grifters and morally challenged individuals who have found the mantle of Conservatism as a convenient front to make reasonable even the horrible idea that Property could be construed as another human being; or that this liberty to own community wealth must always trump (pardon the apt pun) the community's right to share the commonwealth.

Define and respect a real discourse between us all regarding how much -- and under what terms and for what duration -- can be privately held and how much must always be held for the community... the commonwealth.

Doing this will cut them off at the knees and force them to either engage in a discourse they cannot win, or admit their real interest is in getting the next size larger yacht.

D

William L Miller's avatar

Observation of behavior enables understanding of corrupt dishonest “conservative” Republicans who will not engage in a reasonable honest discourse because they operate with an IDEOLOGY. The ideology is hidden but promoted and defended by manipulating opinion and understanding with lying, false fabricated economics, intolerance, fake religion, denial of facts, and rejection of science. Any reasonable discourse must accept democracy and the rule of law but that would be rejected because that would require acceptance of government determined by a majority of the people run by elected people and operating for all the people with government determined and enforced rules of equal justice for rights, sharing and tolerance of diversity that they believe threaten their freedom and liberty. Many are racist and libertarians that want power and control with self determined freedom and liberty that they believe gives them god granted life with freedom and liberty as they claim Ayn Rand has justified with the philosophy of Objectivism. Objectivism opposed all forms or degrees of state collectivism with regulation in favor of laissez-faire capitalism and individual rights. IDEOLOGY blocks reasonable discourse leading to social conflict.

Donald Laghezza's avatar

The idea is to either bait and engage; or document and broadcast their refusal.

The whole purpose is to take back control of the Progressive Brand, and, more importantly, take control of the Alt-right and/or Libertarian Brand.

We have allowed these grifters to both (a) control the Progressive Brand (now seen as Libitards, tree huggers, femmenazis), and, (b) brand their "ownership society" schemes as not really what we remember as conservative (cue the flag waving and the sheriff riding into town "to do what a man has to do.")

the most important first step is to cut the connection between Conservative and "everything is for sale in the market" That requires defining conservative values as far away from "the market"

---"When they talk about freedom of THE MARKET, ask yourself if they are talking about the same thing you remember in the old days... Remember, they now operate a thriving market for drugs, 15 year old girls, and 12 year old boys." might be a possibly too strong a beginning, but we are in a knife fight, so....

Force a true discussion of Conservative vs. Progressive, or chase after them if they flee from it.

Of course this means we need (a) real media vehicle(s) to do this and market/framing savvy people to take control of what is now liberal gobbledeegook.

Singing "It's a small world after all" is not going to work in a knife fight.

D.

Kathy Hughes's avatar

Buckley came by his white Southern sympathies through his mother,

Aloise Steiner Buckley. Aloise was a Catholic native of New Orleans and had an ancestor who died at the Battle of Shiloh while serving in the Confederate Army.

William Farrar's avatar

Every child has a father. Every idea has an origin. And it is my affliction to look for origins and I think that I found it.

It starts with that group of Brownists, led by William Bradford, which we call Pilgrims, they were only 32 of the 102 Puritans that landed that fateful day on (supposedly) Plymouth Rock.. By Ben Franklin's time they had gained political control of Massachusetts, and their ideology had infected the northern colonies.

A decade prior to the revolution a group of Typhoid Mary's, like George Whitefileld, Gilbert Tennet and Jonathan Edwards journeyed into the Southern Colonies to infect the population. After the revolution, a new version of the virus mutated and traveled to the newly created Southern states, and the nascent states then Indian country led by men like Lorenzo Dow the virus has the name the Great Awakening https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Awakening. it was enthusiastically accepted and spread rapidly because, for one thing, it promoted slavery female submission and male dominance as divinely sanctioned, and there is enough ambiguity in it's authorizing document to justify any action from rape and incest to genocide. And that those that refuse him are to be slain

Luke 19:27

E.G,. Job's daughters, the slaughter of Jericho and the Amelkites, 1 Corinthians 14:34–35 and 1 Timothy 2:11–15..Luke 22:36 and Jesus himself said that he did not come to replace the old testment (the law) Matthew 5:17

Judy W.'s avatar

There are actually 2 Independents in the U.S. Senate, Angus King of Maine as well as Sanders, both of whom caucus with Democrats. Being Independent does not preclude them from being the Senate Majority Leader provided they receive the votes from their colleagues.

imhumanru's avatar

A true "conservative" in the old sense would want to conserve the rights that we fought so hard to achieve, particularly since the end of WWII. The new "conservatives" want to completely restructure society- not into something we've had before, but something entirely new.