Heller and the Fraud on the American Public
Richard Nixon put Warren Burger on the Supreme Court as its Chief Justice, a role he served for 17 years. He was a solid conservative (of the ethical variety, not like this corrupt, insane MAGA crowd we have now).
Five years after he retired, he went on PBS in 1991 and said the idea that the Second Amendment guarantees individual gun ownership was:
“One of the greatest pieces of fraud, I repeat the word fraud, on the American public by special interest groups that I have ever seen in my lifetime.”
Seventeen years later, five corrupt Republicans on the Court made that fraud the law of the land, giving us school shooters and the highest rates of gun ownership and gun deaths in the world. And the world’s most profitable armaments industry.
This week’s chapter is about District of Columbia v. Heller, the 2008 decision in which Justice Antonin Scalia claimed — falsely — that the Second Amendment was written by the Framers of the Constitution to give every American the right to own a gun “in defense of hearth and home.”
That phrase sure sounds like something written back in the 1700s, but it’s not: Scalia simply pulled it out of his backside, made it up out of thin air, created it from whole cloth (or whatever other cliche you prefer). It’s a lie, for which there is absolutely no basis in fact. He just wanted it to sound like Madison or Jefferson had written to make his corrupt decision seem legitimate.
In fact, if you read Madison’s notes on the Constitutional Convention — including the lengthy debates about militias — the Virginia ratifying debates, and even the debates in the House of Representatives about the Second Amendment in 1789 nowhere — not in any single place, not a single word or phrase — will repeat Scalia’s scurrilous and deadly invention.
Justice John Paul Stevens was disgusted by Scalia’s naked lie and took it apart piece by piece. The whole thing started in 1960 in a law review article, not in 1789, and ultimately was put there by the gun industry itself. The NRA spent a small fortune, after it’s 1977 takeover by hard-right ideologues, to fund think tanks, phony scholars, and promote a nonexistent history that none of our Founders would have recognized.
I wrote this book in 2019, but since then the corrupt Republicans on the Court have gone even further, with Clarence Thomas writing in the 2022 Bruen case that a gun law survives only if it matches some “historical tradition” of regulation, a bullshit test that has thrown state and local firearms law across the country into absolute chaos.
From The Hidden History of Guns and the Second Amendment, Chapter 21:
Heller: Reinterpreting the Second Amendment
The Court would have us believe that over 200 years ago, the Framers made a choice to limit the tools available to elected officials wishing to regulate civilian uses of weapons, and to authorize this Court to use the common-law process of case-by-case judicial lawmaking to define the contours of acceptable gun control policy. Absent compelling evidence that is nowhere to be found in the Court’s opinion, I could not possibly conclude that the Framers made such a choice.
—Justice John Paul Stevens’s dissenting opinion in District of Columbia v. Heller
The June 26, 2008, Supreme Court decision in the case of District of Columbia v. Heller was a pivotal turn in America’s understanding of the Second Amendment. But it was also a substantial rewrite of the Second Amendment, both in detail and in its very history.
As the historical record clearly shows, that amendment was created to satisfy two constituencies and had virtually nothing to do with the Heller finding that there was an “individual right” to gun ownership in the United States. So who were the groups who pushed for this particular amendment to the brand-new Constitution?
The first was what would become the anti-Federalist faction, led by Jefferson, which was concerned that if the country maintained a standing army during times of peace, members of that army might conspire to overthrow the new government that the founders had just created (something that has happened frequently in history, around the world, from ancient times to today).
The second constituency was the representatives of the slave states, who were concerned that the Article I, Section 8, authority of the federal government to call up an army might end up freeing slaves in the process, and they wanted to protect their state militias, which were largely then known, in those slave states, as slave patrols.
But in 2008, in a squeaker 5–4 decision, Justice Antonin Scalia stretched logic and fantasy to the breaking point to “discover,” for the first time in nearly 230 years, that there was a secret private right to gun ownership “in defense of hearth and home” buried deep within the Second Amendment.
Scalia’s first argument was that the Second Amendment’s use of the phrase “right of the people” to keep and bear arms meant to give everybody in the US the largely unlimited right to gun ownership, just as the First and Fourth Amendments, respectively, protect everybody’s right to free speech and privacy.
This was the first time in the nearly 230-year history of the United States that any court—or any branch of government, for that matter—had suggested such a thing. Thus, in the dissent written by Justice Stevens and joined by Justices Breyer, Souter, and Ginsburg, they noted that Scalia’s new theory about the founders’ intent was, essentially, nonsense made up to keep happy the hard right and the gun lobby that so richly supported the GOP.
“The centerpiece of the Court’s textual argument,” Stevens and his colleagues wrote, summarizing Scalia’s argument, “is its insistence that the words ‘the people’ as used in the Second Amendment must have the same meaning, and protect the same class of individuals, as when they are used in the First and Fourth Amendments. According to the Court, in all three provisions—as well as the Constitution’s preamble, section 2 of Article I, and the Tenth Amendment—‘the term unambiguously refers to all members of the political community, not an unspecified subset.’”
Stevens then took apart Scalia’s argument:
But the Court itself reads the Second Amendment to protect a “subset” significantly narrower than the class of persons protected by the First and Fourth Amendments; when it finally drills down on the substantive meaning of the Second Amendment, the Court limits the protected class to “law-abiding, responsible citizens.”
But the class of persons protected by the First and Fourth Amendments is not so limited; for even felons (and presumably irresponsible citizens as well) may invoke the protections of those constitutional provisions. The Court offers no way to harmonize its conflicting pronouncements.
Scalia also argued, in the absence of any evidence whatsoever from the time of the amendment’s ratification, that the Second Amendment was passed to allow individuals to own guns for self-defense (which was the essence of the Heller case, as Washington, DC, had forbidden people from owning guns even for that reason), rather than a purely military/militia context.
Stevens et al., in their dissent (which, but for one Republican-appointed justice, would have been the majority decision), argued back,
The stand-alone phrase “bear arms” most naturally conveys a military meaning unless the addition of a qualifying phrase signals that a different meaning is intended. When, as in this case, there is no such qualifier, the most natural meaning is the military one; and, in the absence of any qualifier, it is all the more appropriate to look to the preamble to confirm the natural meaning of the text.
The Court’s [Scalia’s] objection is particularly puzzling in light of its own contention that the addition of the modifier “against” changes the meaning of “bear arms.”
They added, quoting a previous Supreme Court decision on the topic,
The phrase “bear Arms” also had at the time of the founding an idiomatic meaning that was significantly different from its natural meaning: to serve as a soldier, do military service, fight or to wage war. But it unequivocally bore that idiomatic meaning only when followed by the preposition “against.” . . .
When each word in the text is given full effect, the Amendment is most naturally read to secure to the people a right to use and possess arms in conjunction with service in a well-regulated militia. So far as appears, no more than that was contemplated by its drafters or is encompassed within its terms. . . .
Indeed, not a word in the constitutional text even arguably supports the Court’s overwrought and novel description of the Second Amendment as “elevat[ing] above all other interests” “the right of law-abiding, responsible citizens to use arms in defense of hearth and home.”
Even a previous Supreme Court chief justice, Nixon appointee Warren Burger, called the idea that the Second Amendment conferred an “individual right” to gun ownership a lie. Explicitly, he said the idea being promoted back when he was on the Court was “a fraud on the American public.”
An early draft of the Second Amendment shows this brightly: it included a conscientious-objector provision for Quakers, letting them opt out of the militia. It read, “A well regulated militia composed of the body of the people, being the best security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed, but no one religiously scrupulous of bearing arms, shall be compelled to render military service in person.”
In fact, through the entirety of James Madison’s notes on the 1787 Constitutional Convention, when military service and gun ownership were extensively discussed and debated, there is not even one single reference to an individual right to own a gun “to defend hearth and home.” (It’s interesting how Scalia used language similar to that in common usage in 1787 to invent his version of early American history: no doubt it caused many people to assume that it was a direct quote from one of America’s Founders, when, in fact, no such phrase exists.)


