59 Comments
User's avatar
alis's avatar

Add the TechBros and Crypto-Creeps to this toxic swill and.....

What we have is a future of robots and AI Slop. This is the very reason why the computer generation oligarchs jumped on the TRump Train. They know when the Dems take power back they will be facing regulation, trust busting, and TAXES.

These frigin' so-called geniuses have unleashed technology that is not ready. Simple math and dates can stymie AI. It "hallucinates", a word meant to charm us once again into thinking of it as human. The only thing human about it is all the information it scrapes from actual humans. Putting that information to use will always require discernment.

MY discernment informs me that money is not speech and corporations are not people. The corrupt, the dumb-asses, and the thieves do not know who they are dealing with. See you in the streets.

Expand full comment
Daniel Solomon's avatar

I agree, but it's always been that way. That's how America came into being. But for reaction to sheepcoating and laws against poaching and the industrial revoluton, our founders would not have had to come to a new world to seek their fortunes.

They would have been fat and happy in England, still living under feudalism.

We had Pennsylvania history in the 7th grade. Our state was a propietorship, controlled by a religious dissenter, Willian Penn, a Quaker. Quakers were despised by both the Church of England and the Puritans at home and would have been put to death by the Inquisition in France or Spain. They were excluded from colonies like Massachiusetts and Connecticut.

The reasons our state opposed King George were that citizens were prohibitted from engaging in British industries, were taxed arbitrarily, and could not cross the Alleghanies, where there was "free" land.

Ben Franklin, a true genius in virtually every sense, out state hero, our archetypal tech bro, created industries that didn't exist before his discoveries and inventions, had an estranged only son who was the British governor of New Jersey, and who rerturned to England, rather than live in our "modern," scientific based society.

As I said yesterday, Trump views those tech bros as marks.Surely some of them have it figured out.

Expand full comment
alis's avatar

Not one Ben Franklin in this crowd. They come up with an app, make a fortune, and hire the geniuses.

They have decided his democratic republic does not serve them.

Expand full comment
William Farrar's avatar

The only way to save ourselves is another 1789.And I don't mean a Constitutional convention either.

Expand full comment
Daniel Solomon's avatar

I dunno know. Altman and Musk wrestliing... 2-3% of all stocks are driving the markets. That means 98% don't participate.

In 1789 we didn't even have a Bill of Rights. Our best moments were in the Reconstruction period. 14th Amendment.

In 1789, America saw the official start of its new constitutional government with George Washington inaugurated as the first President, the U.S. Constitution taking effect, the First Congress convened and established federal departments (State, Treasury, War) and courts, and the Bill of Rights was proposed by Congress, marking a foundational year for the new republic.

Expand full comment
William Farrar's avatar

Internecine quarrels, mean nothing to those not in the family.

1789 is the year of the French Revolution.

The constitution is just words and paper and has not protected us from authoritarianism, and the final arbiter, SCOTUS, has proven to be a facilitator of authoritarianism.

Expand full comment
Daniel Solomon's avatar

I guess you missed A Tale of Two Cities.

Expand full comment
William Farrar's avatar

Nope read it when I was 14.

Revolutions eat their own. I know all about it, but the old order died. And now France has a republic, which is in the verge of extinction, pressured by migration from the Islamic world, tears of Charles Martel, and of hegemonistic threat from Putin.

Expand full comment
Gordon Berry's avatar

That Putin applauds the Lame Duck Felon's new interational goals, we know that he is no longer part of the "Free World".

It makes it most important to remove their cheating in our elections They did it in 2024 and again last week in Tennessee -

Why can't our politicians of both sides stand up and chase down these false election results - their corrections are essential for our future as a Nation that stands by its own Constitution. The evidence of corruption in election vote counting is clear - ask any election expert - ANY...

Expand full comment
Daniel Solomon's avatar

A few of us have been working on it. Only takes a few Congressional Republicans to get started. https://thanedar.house.gov/media/press-releases/congressman-shri-thanedar-introduces-articles-of-impeachment-against-secretary-of-defense-pete-hegseth

The murder on the high seas might be the vehicle. Trumpepstein, also.

Expand full comment
William Farrar's avatar

A few Republicans. Lots of luck with that.

How have the Epstein files worked out? Congress is getting it's documents from the Epstein Estate, nothing from the administration.

Expand full comment
Daniel Solomon's avatar

DOJ drop dead date is December 19.

You are the mouthpiece for MAGA.

Expand full comment
imhumanru's avatar

Oh, stop.

Expand full comment
Daniel Solomon's avatar

Fuck you too.

Expand full comment
imhumanru's avatar

Nice. I suggest you look at Breitbart. They love commenters like you there. Here, not so much.

Expand full comment
MaryPat's avatar

Thank You to our Michigan Congressman Shri Thanedar!!

Expand full comment
MaryPat's avatar

And your important work, Daniel!!

Expand full comment
Tomonthebeach's avatar

Ironic, I suppose, that President Trump labeled US veteran legislators as "TRAITORS, who should be executed" for reminding our troops not to follow illegal orders like blowing up people in speed boats on the high seas - a clear violation of international and US law. Yet, it is not TREASON for that same president to officially sanction Russian annexation of a European nation by a longstanding NATO adversary in his National Defense Strategy, while in that same document insulting our NATO allies by calling them failing nations?

Expand full comment
imhumanru's avatar

Cheating in our elections is only getting worse. And when your cheating gets rewarded with large amounts of money, and if you are corrupt, why would you let it go?

Expand full comment
docrhw Weil's avatar

Just a quick note that the December 1st "New Yorker" has an article detailing the shipment, often in chains, of people from America to various countries. These are folks who either have no ties with their destinations or are being thrown back to the states they fled from. What is hopeful is the work being done to track and fight such actions. What is depressing is the piece's very accurate title, which could have been applied to my wife's grandfather in Nazi Germany, "Disappeared". Just what kind of government do we have anymore?

Expand full comment
William Farrar's avatar

Rep. Adelita Grijalva says she was 'sprayed in the face' during ICE confrontation

Grijalva said that she identified herself as a member of Congress and saw "people directly sprayed," including press and members of her staff.

US Citizens are being arrested and imprisoned by Trumps GESTAPO

American citizens have been deported by ICE, albeit they were children of undocumented mothers, but the precedence is set, It is only going to get worse, there is no check on the regime, not even the judicial system., and if there were the judicial system is in the same situation as Chief Justice Marshall when he ruled that the Indian Removal Act was unconstitutional..he lacked the means of enforcing his ruling.

1789

Expand full comment
Feldman's avatar

One wonders "why the F" didn't ALL the Dems march en masse over to the White House / DOJ and DEMAND some action on the perpetrator(s) of the pepper spraying of the CONGRESSWOMAN Grijalva. Because we are represented by cowards who know they or their families would be next.

Expand full comment
William Farrar's avatar

Yep, frankly yours is a response I never thought of, and I ask the same question, and have the same answer.

Expand full comment
Daniel Solomon's avatar

So where were YOU Nov. 22????????????

Expand full comment
docrhw Weil's avatar

The article alleges that those who complained could be kicked and beaten with full government deniability of these actions. Also, the countries that took these people had no idea who they were and were coerced into accepting them by a combination of threats and bribes from Washington. Likely as not the people would then be sent to prisons on the theory that they must have been bad to be treated like this. We should have realized when “enhanced interrogations” were allowed that any effective outrage on what the feds did had disappeared. Still, maybe this time there won’t be enough “Good Germans” looking the other way to let this continue unopposed.

Expand full comment
William Farrar's avatar

Yeh, the good Germans, like the good Wehrmacht. I fear that all of those deported, are being sent to their deaths.

Expand full comment
G2's avatar

Thom once again has described the awful situation we are in. Six corrupt members of the Supreme Court will continue to do their movements bidding and solidify their control. No scandal seems big enough to topple cabinet members or their boss. Murdering defenseless individuals after blowing their boats up is just another ho hum in the land of trump. Do we need another great recession to get rid of these people? Or are they so entrenched that even that won't get the non voters to vote? Where are the young people? Why aren't campus demonstrations happening countywide?

Expand full comment
Jed's avatar

Thank you for the most consistently worthwhile articles, Mr. Hartmann.

America has become ruled by motivated reasoning reinforcing the power structures that are doing the most damage to our democracy.

We're in the upside down bubble.

Expand full comment
Daniel Solomon's avatar

I never heard of Frédéric Bastiat, but he was right. Black letter Constitutional law these days is nothing more than a rationalization that the little guy has few rights -- despite the text of the Consitution.

Today a case beore the court could cement the unitary executive theory -- that a president (as long as he is a Republcan) is in effect a king. https://www.scotusblog.com/2025/12/trump-v-slaughter-an-explainer/

Expand full comment
Donnelly Wright Hadden's avatar

I do not understand how a multiply millionaire can be reported as giving millions of dollars to a presidential campaign while I am forbidden to give more than $1,800 or thereabouts.

Expand full comment
G.P. Baltimore's avatar

The Supreme Court is once more getting ready to expand the Administration’s power to control our lives by allowing more unregulated firing of Agency officials, in particular FTC. One which the NYTimes quotes justices, “Justice Elena Kagan said such a ruling would “put massive, uncontrolled, unchecked power in the hands of the president.”

“Justice Sonia Sotomayor told the administration’s lawyer that “you’re asking us to destroy the structure of government” and to take away from Congress its ability to insulate independent agencies from political pressures.”

Expand full comment
G.P. Baltimore's avatar

Trump v. Slaughter and

NRSC v. FEC

Expand full comment
William Farrar's avatar

Allow me to take this opportunity to mention, that Trump has finally found a way to push the Epstein affair off the table and out of the public mind. Gone are the cries and demands for full exposure.

Yet again he punks us, first with Mueller, then the documents case,. you have to give the devil his due, he is good at building up expectations, diverting attention, then letting it collapse into a nothing burger.

Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, I can't be fooled again., apparently, most others can.

Now we are chasing another snipe. It maters not that it was murder or a war crime, nothing will happen to any of the bad actors. As a final resort they will be pardoned.

Trump will do what he wants and plans to do, or rather what Kevin Roberts, Yarvin, Vaughn, Miller et al,plan to do, and who is going to stop him?

Expand full comment
Daniel Solomon's avatar

Not true at all.

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/05/us/politics/florida-epstein-grand-jury-documents.html

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/jeffrey-epstein-new-photos-private-island-banking-records/

Rep Garcia gave a press conference a few minutes ago. Still on the job.

The December 8, 2025 episode of 60 Minutes (which aired last night, December 7, 2025) featured an interview with Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, where she discussed the Jeffrey Epstein files and her strained relationship with Trump.

During the interview, Greene stated that Trump was "furious" with her for supporting a bipartisan effort to release all the files related to the case. According to Greene, Trump told her that releasing the files was "going to hurt people".

Key points from the interview regarding the Epstein case:

Trump's Anger: Greene described Trump as "extremely angry" that she signed a discharge petition to make the files public.

Reason for Release Support: Greene explained that she believed the victims, many of whom were abused as young teenagers, deserved to have all the information come out.

Political Fallout: Following her stance, Trump reportedly called her a "traitor" and a "disgrace" to the Republican Party, leading to a public feud and Greene's decision to resign from Congress in January 2026.

Expand full comment
William Farrar's avatar

So Greene's case proves what? That there will be a revolt within the Republican party?

I take notice of how the Republican party, in and out of congress have remained silent.

As regards the Epstein files. What of them, other than providing material for kvetching

After Adelita was sworn in, it became obvious that the Congressional Republicans would have to expose themselves if forced to vote on release of the files, to forestall that problem. it was decided to have all of Congress vote to release them, relying on Pam Bondi and the FBI, to delay, and censor the files.

As I said, the only documents received are from the estate, nothing from the DOJ.

And since Pam has control of the files, she can, and most certainly has, scrubbed them, only she (DOJ) knows what is in them, and can easily withhold tapes.

The real damage in the files is not the paper and emails, but the videos and audio's that Epstein recorded for blackmail.

Nope the Epstein files are a nothing burger, because they are completely under the control of Trump.

The system on which you depend, no longer exists.. Recall how you went to great lengths to prove that the US Marshalls service, worked solely from the Justice Department?

The U.S. Marshals Service helped President Trump's administration and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) by lending its agents, who have broad arrest authority, to bolster immigration enforcement under new DHS directives, shifting them from their traditional fugitive roles to support mass deportation efforts, alongside other agencies like the DEA and ATF, expanding ICE's operational reach against unauthorized immigrants.

U.S. Marshals Service did escort representatives from the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) into the U.S. African Development Foundation (USADF) headquarters in March 2025, after USADF staff initially blocked entry, leading to a standoff that ended when Marshals gained access, though questions arose about the Marshals' involvement and whether Musk's security was deputized, leading to lawsuits.

Yeh, keep on depending on the institutions to protect us, until we are placed in handcuffs and carted off to a concentration camp, many of which Trump is building across the nation.

Expand full comment
G2's avatar

Thanks William good points. Trump and his ilk are in control and seem to be able to get away with anything. I'm hopeful we will have honest midterms. But the prospect that trump will be willing to take his and GOP chances in a fair election is unlikely.

Expand full comment
G2's avatar

Actually I'm hopeful that the Epstein files will weaken him and GOP. Hopeful people will see how poorly he's handled the economy and foreign affairs. Hope that some members of the GOP will - even if only in their own self interest - break with him.

Expand full comment
Jack Carter's avatar

The most logical next step is that there will be no elections next year. If people revolt… they will get beaten, arrested and killed. ICE will be reinforced and follow (for a while) their murderous demented convict and rapist in charge The only last line of defense remains the military because they have the brains and the hardware to fight and get rid of those corrupt fascists. Then get rid of scotus corruption. Seize the assets of the corrupting billionaires… and start anew. Lot of blood on the streets I fear. Good luck

Expand full comment
William Farrar's avatar

Oh there will be elections, the charade must be maintained, there are elections in Hungary, Russia and Turkey, even Iran has elections.

Dominion voting machines were bought by a Republican right wing operative, Redistricting, voter caging, voter restricting laws, like Voter ID, movement and reduction of ballot boxes, and voting booths, MAGA election commissions, (armed) poll watchers (GOP is training 10,000 of them for strategic deployment,. And of course Russian and Chinese interference..

1789

Expand full comment
Jack Carter's avatar

By then… This corrupt lot will think they even do not need anymore to maintain the charade. Let’s see. We are almost there. A few months is quite a long way

Expand full comment
William Farrar's avatar

The regime with the assistance of SCOTUS has proven that the Constitution is irrelevant and a dead letter, and Steve Bannon has said that they are working on a way to make Trump's regime permanent.

All it will take is a national emergency to suspend the Constitution and thus elections.

Trump might not last until 2028, and JD Vance is a bigger threat than Trump, he is Peter Thiel's and the Techno fascist sock puppet and easier to control than Trump.

Trump is controlled by flattery, but is mercurial. Vance is an open vessel, and mindful of who really has the power.

Expand full comment
Daniel Solomon's avatar

"Logical" for MAGATs.

Expand full comment
Tom Halstead's avatar

If enough Democrats, elected and otherwise, consistently make enough noise about Republican corruption throughout the government, we’ll get all the free press we need to offset billionaire BS peddling. That will include active countermeasures (see: Christopher Armitage). That will likely exclude Schumercrats, Jeffriescrats, Third Way types, and all other status quo adherents who have failed to detect, much less act on, the fact that magats at all levels have forever destroyed traditional American politics.

Expand full comment
cliff Krolick's avatar

Tom Good history of our involvement,how we got here in this moment in time. Do you honestly think that there will be a 2026 election? You are extremely intuitive and often read the writing on the wall long before many of us. Bit it puzzles me that you seem quite sure that some semblance of fair elections will occur then. The Owners billionairs, Corporate overlords are to after all these years building to this point will just give up because of an election?

Things are happening very rapidly now and we need a long term national boycott of industries that are going to be supporting this fascist takeover. We do not have the luxury of time and as spring approaches we need to be ready to bring massive demonstrations taken to the heart of this regime with demands that you laid out and a removal of all who is in a co conspiritorial relationship with this fascist regime. Much of this regime is all traitors..traitors and must be punished. We cannot pat them on the back and expect this group of neanderthals to walk away and be quiet without consequences for these despicable actions

Expand full comment
bayjh's avatar

“Whizzer”, Bill and Thurgood were right. Now we need a new America.

Expand full comment
Jan D. Weir's avatar

About the same time, in 1970, the New York Times gave economist Milton Friedman a full page to promote his neoliberal theories. Neoliberalism is a set of conservative values disguised as scholarship. Friedman became Regan's economic guru.

The Democrats adopted many of these principles, especially low taxes on the rich and free trade, deregulation of businesses and banks, and such.

It was the adoption of these policies that began the rise of economic inequality, which is measured by the Gini coefficient. http://piketty.pse.ens.fr/files/capital21c/en/Piketty2014FiguresTables.pdf

We can see that it started its slow, imperceptible rise in the 1970s. Overturning Citizens United, which depends on appointing a majority of Democrat judges, is a long way off. We can examine the causes of this economic inequality that began in the 1970s and develop policies to stop the upward flow of wealth now.

Expand full comment
Clayton James Conway's avatar

Krasnov thinks he is in his element, but he has no idea how far he is down the hole of insanity. The unwillingness to acknowledge the problem he is having is amazing to watch. I wonder if the Repubs in Congress also have any idea how far they are down the hole. Do any of them think they can survive this mess they have supported? I guess we will find out when the Chosen One and his dragon tribe come to town and Hekate enters the Oval Office. Praise God from whom all Blessing flow.

Expand full comment
Feldman's avatar

What country has succeeded in overcoming a totally corrupt supreme court?

Expand full comment