The Hartmann Report

The Hartmann Report

Daily Take

The Billionaires Are Cleared for Takeoff. Why Is the Rest of America Grounded?

The aviation crisis raises a troubling question about what happens when public infrastructure is neglected, workers are stretched thin, and private interests gain influence over essential services…

Thom Hartmann's avatar
Thom Hartmann
Nov 16, 2026
Image by Pixabay.com

Share

In the worst aviation mess since 9/11, every airline in American or heading for America was ordered grounded for a bit over four hours. Thousands of flights were scrubbed and hundreds of thousands of people’s lives and plans were disrupted.

That night, Transportation Secretary and former MTV Reality TV star Sean Duffy and former plumber and now Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin stepped up to the cameras and blamed Congress, which Republicans have fully run for the past two years.

In the ultimate irony — or stupidity — Mullin himself, as a congressman from Oklahoma in 2021, voted against the Biden infrastructure bill that would have put $5 billion into upgrading the FAA’s aging equipment and facilities. Nonetheless, his exact quote this weekend was:

“This is what happens when Congress kicks the can down the road.”

In actuality, this is what happens when a government that once served the people has been taken over by billionaires and massive corporations and turned to their service instead.

Back in 1936, the federal government under FDR took over the nation’s first three air traffic control centers to protect the traveling public, and FDR signed the Civil Aeronautics Act two years later.

It was part of the transformation of our government from one that served the morbidly rich during the Roaring 20s of Republican rule and — after the Republican Great Depression — Democrats took over and began instead to serve the people with the minimum wage, legalized unions. Social Security, rural electricity and telephone subsidies, virtually free college education, and a nationwide air traffic control system.

In the five decades after the Republican Great Depression, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Harry Truman, Dwight Eisenhower, Jack Kennedy, Lyndon Johnson, Richard Nixon, Gerald Ford, and Jimmy Carter taught America and the world a great truth: a middle class is not a normal thing, and if a country wants one it must be created by direct government intervention in the marketplace and government supports for infrastructure like our air traffic system.

Prior to FDR’s New Deal, America had never had a broad middle class that encompassed more than half of us. No other country in the world had, either.

As recently as 1900, for example, women couldn’t vote, senators were appointed by the wealthiest power brokers in the states, and poverty stalked America. As the federal Council of Economic Advisors noted, that year fewer than 10 percent of homes had electricity, fewer than 14 percent of Americans finished high school, one-tenth of all children died in infancy, and the average lifespan was a mere 47 years.

This was what we’d today call a libertarian or neoliberal America: no Social Security, no government healthcare or nutrition programs, no housing assistance, no protections from predatory bankers and brokers, only the rich could afford college, no Medicare, unions, or minimum wage. In large part, that was because there was no income tax to pay for such programs, and federal receipts were a mere 3 percent of GDP.

Then government changed sides when Democrats took over in 1933. FDR imposed a top income tax rate of 90 percent on the morbidly rich, 50% on corporate profits, and passed legislation giving average people the right to unionize, balancing the power equation between management and labor.

The result was that by 1980 well over 60 percent of Americans were in the middle class, and for half a century Washington DC largely worked for the people who paid for it.

That was also the era when our government used that tax money to build gleaming new schools and airports across the country, the interstate highway system, and — for its time — sophisticated air traffic control system in the world.

The morbidly rich, though, hated every bit of it. In his 1953 book The Conservative Mind, Russell Kirk argued that FDR’s, Truman’s, and Eisenhower’s growing middle-class would soon become a threat to America; without clearly defined classes and power structures, he argued, our country would slide into chaos and eventually, communism.

At first, people thought he was a crackpot. The middle class dream had reached over half of America, healthcare was cheap because hospitals and insurance companies were required to be nonprofits and private equity buying up doctors’ practices hadn’t yet been legalized, and our highway and air systems were the envy of the world.

But then came the 1960s.

Kirk and his colleagues like William F. Buckley had predicted that if the middle class got too big, women would want to get out of the kitchen and bedroom, young people would cease to respect their elders, and minorities would “forget” their “place” in the social and economic order. These three “disasters” would bring about the ruin of America and perhaps even throw us into the kind of communism that had seized the USSR.

And, sure enough, during that decade women were demanding rights (the birth control pill was legalized in 1961), young people were refusing to go to Vietnam and burning their draft cards (I was in SDS), and the Civil Rights movement had reached a dramatic and effective peak leading to passage of the Civil Rights and Voting Rights Acts in 1964 and 1965.

The donor class that owned the Republican Party concluded, as draft cards, bras, and inner cities were on fire, that Kirk and his friends had been right all along: America was disintegrating.

They mistook the birth pains of a new and better country and social order for anarchy, chaos, and an open door to communism. Lewis Powell’s Memo offered them a way to “save America” — it was an early version of Project 2025, an effort to turn us back to the “stable society” we had in 1900.

Thus, when Reagan cut a treasonous deal with the Iranian Ayatollah to keep the American hostages until after the election, destroying Jimmy Carter’s chances for re-election, the explicit goal of the morbidly rich white men funding the so-called Reagan Revolution was to take the middle class down a peg to end the protests.

And the place Reagan chose to start his “revolution” to “Let’s Make America Great Again” (his campaign slogan) was the air traffic control tower.

Conservative acolytes of Kirk, Buckley, and Powell were virulently anti-union; they saw these democratic organizations that operated within hierarchical, kingdom-like corporations with their CEOs and senior management rulers as the camel’s nose of communism under the tent’s edge of capitalism.

So, when on August 3, 1981, about 13,000 air traffic controllers walked off the job asking for better pay and working conditions, two days later Reagan fired 11,345 of them.

It was the GOP’s open declaration of war on labor unions, crushed PATCO (the Professional Air Traffic Controllers Organization union) in less than a week, and told every employer in America that it was open season on working class people.

Reagan then massively cut FDR’s taxes on rich people that had built America, and raised taxes on working-class people 11 times. RAND’s Carter Price calculates that if incomes had kept growing the way they did during the 1933-1980 New Deal years, the bottom 90 percent of us would’ve earned $79 trillion more and today’s billionaire class would be the merely rich instead of the morbidly rich.

Reagan’s legacy continues; forty-five years after he crushed PATCO, the FAA is still about 3,500 controllers short, with many of them working mandatory overtime and six-day weeks. This after Musk’s DOGE fired 400 people from the FAA who were responsible for maintaining and upgrading the air traffic control system, and another 1,

200 took the early retirement DOGE was offering.

Subscribe for free to continue reading

Enter your email and get every post from The Hartmann Report.
Already have an account? Sign in
© 2026 Thomas Hartmann · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.