36 Comments

Thank you so so much Thom for all you do. I just received one of your Books: 'The Hidden History of the American Oligarchy" and I'm really excited to start reading it!!

Can't say I'm not terrified though. Trying to stay hopeful. Least we get to watch the Orange menace squirm for awhile. That gives me some joy. 😆 Keep the faith dear friends. ❤️🇺🇸💙

Expand full comment
Apr 18·edited Apr 18

Writing as a Jew and lifelong Zionist, I think Israel's "democratic roots" are largely mythical. More democratic than the autocracies of virtually every Arabic-speaking nation? Sure, but isn't that a case of damning with faint praise? Even in the much more idealistic time of ben Gurion, the blessings of liberty were not uniformly distributed.

Expand full comment

I put a ‘like’ on this, but I don’t really like it. I hate it. I just agree with it.

I am immensely pleased to see and read Thom’s clear-eyed and frank description of what we are up against!! And Putin and Xi are only a couple of the most visible autocrats and strongmen — Trump genuflects at their altars, and at Orban’s, and Erdogan’s, and Bibi’s … and even Kim Jong Un’s!

I am thinking back a bit, though, to a point when I started to lose patience with the far, progressive Left, who tended to crab about centrist and mainstream politicians and the press when they talked about Russian interference and shenanigans aimed at destabilizing and ousting the US from its pre-eminent position as the strongest and most influential world power, after the break-up o the Soviet Union.

Too many progressive voices several years ago loudly crabbed that American pols and the press were going after Russia in a knee-jerk fashion, in an old Cold War mode, and they made out that warning about the danger of Russian schemes against us was unfair and inaccurate — to see so much “harm” being done by our old nemesis, Russia {and Putin} was supposedly replaying old tapes, and we should be paying more attention to our own failures.

For sure, the US has its own failures and mistakes to own up to and deal with. We have our own imperial footprint and chicanery around the world to acknowledge, and we need to resolve to do better.

It seemed to me, though, that some strong voices on the Left were being — whether they meant to be or not — apologists for Putin, or were serving as “knee-jerk” critics of US empire, losing sight of the REAL dangers that Russia {and China, for that matter} presents. And now, we see Putin and Russia and the disinformation state clear. And it is FORMIDABLE.

DJT went on and on about how unfair “Russia-Russia-Russia” was in the run up to and the aftermath of his 2016 “election.”

But contrary to his claims, the Mueller report revealed that Trump and his minions WERE ACTUALLY seriously involved with and influenced by Russian actors, as was our public media during the 2016 campaign season.

And it’s happening again — now.

I’m more than pleased to hear voices on the far Left recognizing and trying to do something to counteract the disinformation that is come at us fast and furious…

{There’s PLENTY for us to fix in this country — but we need to be able to walk and chew gum — if we take our eye off the disinformation coming at us, we may lose the White House to the Oligarchs in November. We will lose the chance to ever fix the things in our own government that we progressives have had our eye on for decades … Our democracy is not perfect, lord knows — but we must preserve it, if we hope to make it better. VOTE BLUE.}

Expand full comment

Thom, this is an idea I posted to Mary Trump's last substack article. Not about oligarch corruption per se, but about strengthening democracy. I'd like feedback on its practicality.

I did an online query that says the net worth of the New York Times is 7.17 billion dollars. Might someone start a fundraiser to buy out the Ochs-Sulzberger family and other stockholders, and create a non-profit newspaper without corrupting influences? Donors should be Members, not Shareholders, so votes regarding management would be one per member, not one per share. Democracy in operation should be an effective shield against corruption. Hopefully, some wealthy idealists might make major donations Despite that management rule.

The IRS has a website regarding charitable donations. The second group of qualifying organizations is defined as:

"A community chest, corporation, trust, fund, or foundation, organized or created in the United States or its possessions, or under the laws of the United States, any state, the District of Columbia or any possession of the United States, and organized and operated exclusively for charitable, religious, educational, scientific, or literary purposes, or for the prevention of cruelty to children or animals;"

The proposed organization seems to clearly qualify: "operated exclusively for charitable, religious, educational, scientific, or literary purposes" This should make very substantial donations from wealthy donors practical. (This idea might be applied to buy out other problematic corporations as well.)

Expand full comment

What a great article you wrote Thom. I just wish we could get some of the Donald cult to read or at least listen to your radio program.

The government owns about 28% of all the land in America. I think Donald has his wandering eyeball set on acquiring and privatizing that land. For himself of course!

We need Biden to start using the bully pulpit and preaching to the Donald base about the vices of a dictatorship and the virtues of a democracy.

Looks to me like the billionaires are all lined up at the crap table and they're betting on the fascists. They are also showing no brains as well. Only China may be able to pull that one off, but 90% of dictatorships turn into total dumps. The rich don't want to pay more taxes they would rather let the peasants perish one way or the other!

Expand full comment

Thanks, Thom, for all you do and have done for democracy and humanity. However, our human instinct to line-up behind a strong (rich) man is the result of our massive human overpopulation, and not found in our ancestral ecologically balanced migratory Hunter-Gatherer clans/bands, who numbered 1/3,000 th of our current 8B+, and were egalitarian.

Expand full comment

Amazing that outright fascism in America is soft toast to the media. In fact the media owners are supporters of fascism and allow fake views to dominate and turn society favoring anti-democratic propaganda some of which are the views of dictators & Putin. Voices against democratic institutions around the world are domestic groups inside America. Hard to believe that such could exist but does.

I hope the Dem Party recognizes the danger and will use a base voter campaign of 3 or 4 economic issues daily repeated to get out the vote that a purely cultural campaign, as needed as they are, within the campaign are by themselves insufficient as the 2022 loss of the House showed plainly.

Expand full comment

Breaking news: Israel seems to have "retaliated" with bombs inside Iran near Isfahan. Now the world has two "strongmen" ensconced in incompatible religious entitlement, facing off.

Expand full comment

Thom's hopes are my hopes.

Here's the thing----Netanyahu seems determined to start enough fires causing a major Middle-East meltdown. Biden and Putin seem to understand. Russia voted for the cease-fire at the UN, and the President, despite hating Hamas and their attack, sees that suffering and death in Gaza must end.

So here we are willing to provide arms/funding, but we sure as hell do not want to go to war. So far, so good? Obviously not for those who died and are suffering. Biden will try to help not hurt. Then there is the other guy....

If Trump is elected, will war be his focus? He will be very busy destroying every American agency and putting in radical Republicans where he can. He definitely will pick theft and corruption from the triad, but war? He'll just let Putin win wherever he chooses. If he chooses a NATO country, what an f-ing mess that will be.

Congress has the right to declare war, but the President can refuse to activate or send troops. Trump is a contrarian, a psychopath, and owned by Putin. We The People and America means nothing to Trump, and Putin hates us. Hope, but VOTE!

Expand full comment

Actually, I am reading this after I just got done watching 2 videos that cover 3000 years of German history. The series is in English and therefore I am going to post them for those who do not know anything of German history than the Holocaust. Each episode is around 59 minutes, and I think there was a commercial in the middle of each one. It is divided into 8 sections. The first thing that I thought was that one can see how exhausted European countries are of war because of their long histories of just battling and battling and then there is 100 year period that is less contentious, and then 2 world wars. Why would they want to be in a war again, particularly after having been in 2 World Wars in recent times. In any case, it made me think about the lessons from this as applied to Putin. One, Putin must know his German history. So, while he claims to model himself after Ivan the Terrible, I think he is also modeling himself after Frederick the Great of Prussia who successfully expanded territory and won wars using 'good military strategy." He also put a lot of money into his military. That was the best funded part of the government. Secondly, Putin looks at Hitler's mistakes in taking on both Europe, where he was having success, but then joining Japan in declaring war on the US who came into the war again, fresh as they had in WWI. He could not win on both fronts, just like Germany could not in WWI. Hitler did not learn the lessons of the past, but I think that Putin is looking at staving off the USA in any way he can, because no way can he defeat Europe's largest democracy if the USA steps into battle in a more direct way. In fact, he does not have the manpower unless he borrows from China (who would China send?) or Iran (who would the Ayatollah sendhe needs his military just to keep his people from an uprising), or (North Korea?) would Jung Un really send people to Ukraine where they could escape and fight for the other side? Not sure. Would have a harder time controlling their slave-like conditions. So, when Putin said he would rather have Biden in the White House I can see that as a truth even if it rings disingenuous. He knows that Biden is not likely to send our troops when the model we have is of sending our old weapons, and providing intelligence and military advice. It is a safe formula. Also, we know that unlike the other presidents of our time, Biden actually has had a child in the military, and will not unnecessarily risk US lives. These are the Hitler conditions that Putin is not expecting to face. So, as long as he can stave off a second front by waiving his nukes, he is assured of only fighting Ukraine, however unfairly. I am glad that German Vice Chancellor Habeck went to Kiev. It sounds like he went out of frustration with how much more Germany could be doing and is not, as Scholz is kowed into not doing enough by fear of Putin, and more recently a fear of the growing numbers and therefore prowess of members the AfD, who I have been thinking since covid have been stirred up by Putin's bots, and those of his allies. Those people are discontent over everything and nothing. I know people in Germany who are discontent even though they want for nothing and have a better lifestyle than most Americans, just because of insurance coverage and vacations. The Right and the Left are pro Putin, and since my mom's school friend is a member of the Left party, I get to hear what the standard thinking is from her and her partner. They both believe that Putin had to go into Ukraine because Russian speaking Zelenskiy was stopping the people of the Russian diaspora from speaking Russian, and he had to rescue them from mistreatment. I asked her, so should the native Americans accept domination by the US government not allowing them to speak their own language? And, do you want your grandchildren and great grandchildren to grow up speaking only Russian and only learning Russian culture if Putin decides to invade Germany? I have to really illustrate this for them, just as I am trying to illustrate to youth why disaffection for Trump should not translate into not getting involved, but into to voting for Biden. I have several people I am working on, on some I have made inroads on. So, I am not saying I am correct in my thinking about Putin, but these videos lead me to these thoughts, just being formed.

Part 1 https://youtu.be/0ZR9B2KIJBI?si=k3jUxpHkwSVjRHfG

Part 2 https://youtu.be/rF_V41lyqsY?si=7QF8issIX2b4Cj3K

If you have a different interpretation I would love to hear it. I think we could extend these lessons to all of the dictators that Thom mentions. They learn some lessons from wars, but theirs are how to exploit weaknesses. We are trying to learn the lessons of what is the kind of life we want to live and support.

Expand full comment

I’d recommend reading Apeirogon by Colum McCann. How can Israelis and Palestinians work together? Some do.

Expand full comment

Fortunately, the Senate passed the aid packages for Ukraine, Israel, and Taiwan last night AND the Gaza aid package, as well by a margin of 95 for (including Republicans!)-20 against.

Expand full comment

We should include GW Bush and Dick Cheney in that list of non-democratic leaders that took their countries into unprovoked wars. With the USA this cost the taxpayers more than $7 trillion and destroyed any chance for women to have equal rights. It was however very profitable for Cheney with his Halliburton stock that doubled in value while he was in office.

Not considered is that the US provoked Russia's invasion of the Ukraine with U.S. led eastward expansion of NATO. The capitalist elites want to crush what they cannot control and profit enormously from the sales of NATO compatible weapons to new members.

Israel has never been a true democracy and apartheid and ethnic cleansing has been ongoing since 1948 with millions of displaced Palestinians who have been forcibly removed from their ancestral lands and had their homes and family members obliterated.

The Europeans and the Jews in the United States like the idea of sending the Jews displaced by the Nazi to Israel instead of having to deal with them in the U.S. (which had turned away Jewish refugees). Germany, France, Belgium, Poland, etc.

In effect Israel became a dumping ground for the Jews and that the land was already occupied was of no consequence. for the Imperial powers in charge. They were used to displacing native populations by force for profit.

Expand full comment

Thom—Perhaps it’s not evident to us in an older generation, but there is substantial disinformation issue happening on TikTok on this front to the Millennials and Zoomers. This very complex situation is being oversimplified into TikTok moments. Your piece helps illustrate the complexity of all the intersecting strands in the region. None of that is captured in TikTok. I know from conversations with friends in Abu Dhabi that the complexity and interlocking risks are not lost on those in the region.

One might rightfully ask if there is some algorithmic manipulation in TikTok that helps to amplify a distortion of simplicity.

I keep hoping that the noise over TikTok ownership can somehow be directed into reform of Section 230 and assigning accountability to social media. Perhaps hope springs external?

Expand full comment

Israel has never been a democracy, it is a theocracy. Nearly 700,000 of its population are settlers in the West Bank. The vast majority of the population could care less about what its government does to the Palestinian people as they are not Jews, and those who are not Jewish have little to no rights. Now you are including Iran in your "axis of evil?" It's ironic that you wrote a book on oligarchy yet your propaganda is largely in support of its most basic tenet--perpetual war and world domination. As for Ukraine, nobody who favors the funneling of billions in weapons can tell me how Ukraine will ever emerge victorious. Every single military expert that I have seen sees no road to military victory, but administration members have admitted that money on Ukraine is well spent because the Ukrainians are doing our fighting against Russia, hundreds of thousands dying in the process. It is the same in Israel, with the US directly supplying the IDF with the weapons to carry out its campaign of genocide. You can distract all you want, but too many of us are not buying the distraction away from what the Democratic Party really represents and their culpability in ushering in the era of Trump.

Expand full comment

What an interesting statement from Mike Johnson coming after his visit to Mar-a-Lago: https://www.c-span.org/video/?535006-1/speaker-mike-johnson-holds-news-conference

Expand full comment